Hickory vs Oak Flooring: Pros, Cons & Differences

Hickory and oak are among the most most well-liked wooden floorings. Hopefully, you might be in flooring enterprise both putting in or planning to improve your ground. Imagining you will have fastidiously thought of your choice and been left with Hickory and Oak as your solely choice. Each are hardwood and accessible in stable or engineered planks.

Hickory is among the hardest, hardest wooden principally used for axe deal with. It’s a wonderful distinctive flooring that may brighten your own home with a country look. However, Oak is among the hottest hardwood floorings. Typically, crimson oak and white oak are the generally used species for flooring.

Hickory vs Oak flooring: Variations

Has a Janka hardness ranking of 1820.White oak has a Janka ranking of 1350 and crimson oak 1220.
As a consequence of its hardness, its costlier than oak. Crimson oak is a less expensive choice than white oak and hickory.
Liable to rot, thus require therapy in opposition to rot.White and crimson oak is extra immune to rot than hickory.
Immune to bugs and Heartwood decay.Liable to bugs and heartwood decay than hickory.
Can final tens of many years with minimal important care in your flooringIt will probably last more with correct care. Though might be outdone by hickory
It has selection, all 16 species can be utilized for flooring.Restricted in selection. Solely white and crimson oak are extra most well-liked for flooring.
Good for staining than oakIt may be stained to a most well-liked look
 Would possibly improve home worth considerably. This, nonetheless, relies on particular person style and desire Will increase the home values considerably, although may be lower than hickory
hickory vs oak flooring pro cons and differences


Sturdiness- Hickory or Oak?

Each are hardwood flooring and accessible as stable or engineered flooring. The stable varieties might be refinished a number of occasions for each. However for engineered plank, they will solely be refinished as soon as. Each can face up to excessive visitors areas flooring. Hickory resists scratches and dings greater than each crimson and white oak.

Water Resistance

Moisture and water is an issue with hickory and oak flooring. Swelling and shrinking will happen on account of moisture for each.


Each might be stained to have the specified outlook


UV rays or photosensitivity is a matter for each flooring varieties. Picture-sensitivity can have an effect on any sort of flooring except it’s in a room with no mild. For each floorings, you’ll want to think about home windows and the quantity of sunshine every room receives.

Color and Look

Each floorings have totally different distinctive kinds and intrinsic magnificence. Hickory has distinct diversified grains.

Heat and Sound Absorption

Hickory and oak flooring present heat in your ft. you don’t have to fret about strolling on it barefooted. Each have good absorption traits for your own home.

Well being Results

Hickory and Oak give out mud that may trigger well being respiratory issues, all the time put on protecting gear.

Selection, Designs, and Types

The 2 flooring varieties can be found in varied kinds and totally different board widths that can provide you a sensible choice for the specified look.

Elevated Dwelling Worth

Probably the greatest vital advantages of hardwood flooring is elevated home worth. The usage of each hickory and Oak will increase the worth of your property lots. The usage of a hickory and oak ground may assist to promote your own home simply.

Recognition- Hickory or Oak?

Which of the 2 hickory and oak is usually put in in properties? This may increasingly rely on the design and kinds one is on the lookout for. Nonetheless, Oak flooring is extra widespread than hickory. For the owners on the lookout for distinctive grains, hickory turns into their desire. Value could also be one other determinant for recognition, hickory is a bit more costly than oak.


White oak takes the lead right here, its fairly exhausting and expands much less compared with hickory. Hickory is the toughest, though it expands and contracts barely greater than oak. White oak is extra secure than hickory. If you happen to determine to stay to hickory in areas with excessive humidity and temperature adjustments, choose engineered hickory. Engineered hickory hooked up to the sub-floor reduces the contracting and increasing considerably. These traits for white oak makes it sturdy to be used for wine barrels and boats for a lot of many years.


Hickory is costlier than oak. White oak is cheaper than crimson oak. Crimson oak is more durable than white oak. This can be attributed to totally different costs of respective flooring. Lately survey exhibits the value of hickory flooring to vary from $3.2 to $7.5 whereas oak flooring vary from $2.6 to $5.8. As well as, the costs might range because of the variety of knots and different minor imperfections. The set up price typically stay s between $3 to $4 per sq. foot.

Hickory vs Oak ground Professionals and Cons

Hickory flooring pro and cons

Making the choice on which ground to put in requires extra understanding of the professionals and cons of your flooring selections. Price implications, putting in fees, cleansing and upkeep price amongst others are main concerns.

Professional’s of Hickory hardwood flooring

  • Hickory has distinctive intrinsic grain patterns distinct type oak flooring.
  • Hickory may be very engaging with its rustic look.
  • Hickory flooring planks are extra fashionable. Planks deal higher with grains’ complexity and permit owners to take pleasure in these lovely grains.
  • A great flooring stain could make numerous distinction. It may be the boldest selection relying on model and residential furnishings.
  • Straightforward upkeep price. Straightforward to wash, easy sweeping and Vacuuming is simply sufficient to take care of your hickory ground.
  • Hickory is bugs and Heartwood decay-resistant, an issue present in different floorings. This allows hickory to retain its magnificence for many years

Cons of Hickory Hardwood Flooring

  • Rustic look is probably not engaging and interesting to some folks.
  • Hickory has grains variations which can require numerous work for the flooring to be cohesive.
  • Take into account hiring a professional installer with expertise in putting in this nice lovely flooring. The skilled installer could possibly take care of altering patterns higher than DIYs.
  • Rot and decay are a problem, thus obligatory therapy must be completed which is a further price.

Professional’s of Oak Hardwood Flooring

oak flooring pro and cons
  • Oak is extra secure, it may be put in in an space with excessive humidity and excessive temperature adjustments.
  • Oak is the preferred selection for Householders
  • Oak price inexpensive than Hickory.
  • It may be stained to the popular shade.
  • Low upkeep price. Common cleansing and mopping will maintain your oak ground superior.

Oak Hardwood Flooring – Professionals and Cons

Cons of Oak Hardwood Flooring

  • Quite common thus not a sensible choice for owners on the lookout for a novel contact of hardwood.
  • Tough to put in. It requires you to rent an expert installer, not for DIYs.
  • Canine and cat claws, excessive heeled footwear and furnishings are more likely to go away scratches and dents in your ground. Furnishings beneath pads might assist overcome this downside

Leave a Comment