Oak vs. Maple Flooring: Pros and Cons Compared

Oak flooring is sweet particularly for those who’re in search of sturdy hardwood flooring. However how does it examine to maple? Is maple flooring higher than oak and the way do they examine? If that is your query too, this text takes a deep dive into the comparability, variations, professionals, and cons of oak vs maple.

The selection between the 2 sorts of wood flooring is normally knowledgeable by completely different features akin to sturdiness, coloration choices, power, and hardness. Typically, these two wooden flooring sorts provide the identical qualities, with delicate variations that may be ignored.

Most owners could select to go together with maple, however oak can be pretty as in style. Oak normally offers a lifetime efficiency as a result of it may be refinished. If completed by an expert, sanding, coloration matching and touch-ups can provide it a superior look over a very long time.

Which one is more durable – Oak or Maple?

Relating to power, maple is more durable than oak wooden. The Janka hardness check is commonly used to find out the power of wooden by measuring the resistance of a wooden pattern to denting and put on and tear.

Based on the oak vs maple hardness Janka check, oak has a rating of 1290 whereas maple is rated 1450. Due to this fact, of the 2, maple will show the toughest hardwood materials for flooring, however that doesn’t imply crimson oak performs so poorly when it comes to sturdiness.

Should you’re utilizing this comparability to find out the toughest hardwood flooring to put in, the most effective could be hickory, which is rated 1820 on the Janka hardness check.

The hardness check is beneficial in terms of deciding the place you need to set up the ground. For instance, some folks need to set up a wooden flooring in excessive site visitors areas akin to stairs to attenuate harm.

Others could select to put in both oak or maple for aesthetic functions. White oak and crimson oak, for instance, are very stunning although they might not be the toughest in comparison with maple hardwood.

Arduous with a score of 1290 Janka hardnessTougher then oak with a score of 1450 Janka hardness
Sturdy flooring,and laborious sufficient to last more.Extremely sturdy flooring that may final for many years.
Pink Oak extra in style resulting from heavy grains, nice-warm-rosy undertone.Pretty in style in contrast with Oak.
Has completely different colours. White Oak stains evenly with stunning end.Has creamy look and provides aesthetic worth when utilized in some home sections.

Sturdiness – Which one lasts longer?

In some instances, the sturdiness of wooden is set by wanting on the sample and depth of the grain. Each maple and oak could have very completely different grain patterns although their weight is kind of the identical. Their sturdiness can be pretty the identical.

Word that hardness doesn’t immediately translate into sturdiness. The longevity and look of all stable hardwood and engineered wooden flooring relies upon extra on the situations and technique of set up.


Which of the 2 is probably the most generally put in in properties? Folks in search of the toughest picket flooring typically select hickory, however in terms of maple and oak, the recognition index of oak is pretty excessive.

The rationale why crimson oak could be very in style is that it has pretty heavy grains and has a pleasant, heat, rosy undertone. This provides it the sting of magnificence in addition to the impression of hardness or sturdiness.

To the attention, this durability of floors may be simply plausible however as per the exams, it could not outdo maple.


Oak has completely different colours that make it very engaging for various house owner flooring wants. The white oak flooring stain evenly, making it find yourself with a wonderful end that might not be simply achieved with maple.

Maple, alternatively, additionally has its personal magnificence factors. It has a creamy look, and that’s the reason some folks use it to reinforce the aesthetics of some sections of their homes.


Maple vs oak value, maple is barely value pleasant than oak with a price ticket of $7 to $11 per sq. foot for supplies and set up. Oak flooring value extra with worth vary of 1$ to six$ greater than maple flooring per sq. foot. Nevertheless, in some instances the costs could also be about 15$ or extra per sq. foot or extra for each oak and maple flooring.

Oak vs Maple Flooring Execs and Cons

Earlier than you select, perceive what professionals and cons you’ll be coping with – from cleansing to upkeep, value implications to set up costs, and way more.

Execs of Oak Hardwood Flooring

The next are the benefits of oak flooring in comparison with maple.

  • The soundness of oak flooring is greater in comparison with that of maple, and even hickory on this case.
  • The aesthetic worth of white oak flooring is spectacular and that’s the reason it’s a extra frequent flooring possibility for householders preferring hardwood flooring.
  • Oak stains very nicely, leaving the planks wanting uniform and professionally completed.
  • Oak is cheaper in comparison with maple, so for those who’re constructing a house on a finances, this will slot in so nicely for you.

Cons of Oak Hardwood Flooring

Regardless of the benefits, chances are you’ll discover oak picket flooring to have the next disadvantages:

  • Oak is a really heavy hardwood and as such, it might probably have critical results on the ground particularly if not put in by a radical skilled.
  • Blight can be a standard downside with oak bushes, and in some cases, it could have an effect on the looks and power of the wooden.

Benefits of Maple Wooden Flooring

Maple is by far the primary selection for most individuals developing modern properties. It provides quite a lot of finishes to select from whereas nonetheless giving spectacular sturdiness. Listed here are a few of the professionals of maple wooden flooring over oak.

  • Maple has a delicate grain construction, making it an important selection for ending giant and open areas.
  • It’s appropriate for each excessive site visitors and low site visitors areas of the house.
  • Maple flooring are extra secure in comparison with picket flooring manufactured from different species of hardwood bushes.
  • Maple flooring are extra immune to dents and floor scratches resulting from its’ little porosity.

Disadvantages of Maple

Although maple is normally chosen over oak, it has its personal downsides, a few of that are as follows:

  • Regardless of the steadiness and hardness, some maple flooring begin to bend and twist sooner than oak, particularly in excessive climate situations.
  • The colour selection of your flooring in terms of maple could also be a bit restricted until you select from prefinished ones. Should you’re seeking to patch up a small space of your property, chances are you’ll discover it tough to seek out the fitting coloration.

In conclusion, deciding on between oak and maple hardwood flooring may be difficult. Every of those two species of bushes makes hardwood flooring that comes with its personal benefits and downsides. What you shouldn’t neglect is that each maple and oak flooring would require particular upkeep to maintain them wanting nice and even final lengthy.

Maple is lighter, brings a recent look in your own home, with a good efficiency at an inexpensive price ticket. Oak flooring offers a conventional properties attraction with longevity, extra grain sample, however extra pricey. White oak flooring ranks on best choice for an space that wants water and decay-resistant wooden flooring. Oak flooring ranks as the most suitable choice the place grain sample counts to supply a richer flooring apple.Is Maple a tough or delicate wooden?

Maple is a hardwood from broad-leaved deciduous bushes. It’s obtainable in many types rock, laborious, delicate silver, sugar, all of that are hardwoods since they’ve tree leaves. The tree leaves look determines it as hardwood whereas the needle-like or scales teams it as softwood.Is maple wooden costly?

Maple has nice aesthetics grain that will increase its demand. Nevertheless, it’s extra ample and grows bigger making it much less costly than Walnut however nonetheless extra pricey than some hardwoods resulting from its power and attractiveness.Is Oak low cost or costly?

Oak is among the most sought and used woods for furnishings, flooring, and different structural use. Nevertheless, it one of the crucial costly hardwood flooring when it comes to preliminary prices however inexpensive when in comparison with walnut and different upkeep prices.

Leave a Comment